Canadian index mutual funds were among the better financial innovations to come along in the past few decades. Still the popularity of ETFs may soon eclipse them

Canadian index mutual funds are specialized mutual funds that aim to equal the performance of a Canadian market index, such as the S&P/TSX 60.

Canadian index mutual funds do show better long-run performance than many actively managed mutual funds with long-term track records. That’s partly because index mutual fund fees run as low as 0.70% of assets per year, compared to 2.5% or more on many actively managed mutual funds. ETF fees are in most cases even lower than those of index mutual funds (more on ETFs below).

How to Make Money with ETFs Learn everything you need to know in 'The ETF Investor's Handbook' for FREE from The Successful Investor. ETFs Guide for Canadian Investors: Find the best way to invest in ETFs with low fees, low risk & high satisfaction.  I consent to receiving information from The Successful Investor via email. I understand I can unsubscribe from these updates at any time.

Advantages of Canadian index mutual funds

One big advantage of index mutual funds is that they can help you avoid the risk of choosing a mutual fund with a management style that virtually guarantees below-average long-term performance. This is particularly important when searching for the best Canadian mutual funds.

For example, in our view, the best Canadian mutual funds pursue trading or sector-rotation approach belong in this sub-par category. Managers of these funds try to outperform the market by betting on relatively short-term trends. This can work in any one year, say. But in any one decade, the top funds are generally run by conservative managers who focus on long-term growth in the economy.

Another advantage of index mutual funds is that they can give investors with limited funds a low-cost way to get some stock-market exposure. They can also be a good starting point for a registered education savings plan (RESP), or an in-trust account. Many investors also consider them when they invest funds in their tax-free savings accounts (TFSAs).

If you want to invest in Canadian index mutual funds, you can buy them through almost any mutual fund company. This includes the Big Five banks.

Three tips for investing in the best Canadian mutual funds

1. Avoid mutual fund managers who trade heavily

If you do decide to invest in mutual funds, then be aware that some of the most dangerous mutual funds are those run by mutual fund managers who honestly believe they can increase their performance by frequent in-and-out trading. Many of these managers fail to realize how close their fund’s performance comes to disaster each year, until disaster finally strikes.

If you add up a heavy trader’s losses at the end of a given year, they may amount to a high percentage of their fund’s assets (25%, for example). That may seem perfectly acceptable to the mutual fund manager, so long as the profits on their winning trades are significantly higher than that (for example, 75% of assets).

If the mutual fund manager guesses wrong a few times, however, it’s all too easy to reverse those figures: that is, have losses totalling 75% of assets and profits totalling 25%, so that the fund loses 50% of its capital. If the manager delves into low-quality or highly volatile choices, as heavy traders are apt to do, then the fund’s performance can drop.

2. Beware of buying vaguely described Canadian mutual funds

Be careful investing in Canadian mutual funds that show wide disparities between the fund’s portfolio and the investments that the sales literature describes.

It’s often hard to find out much about who is making the decisions, what sort of record they have, and what sort of investing they prefer. We always take a close look at an mutual fund’s performance and investments to see if they differ from what the prospectus or sales literature would lead investors to expect.

3. Avoid buying Canadian mutual funds with anonymous managers

This includes buying Canadian mutual funds run by committees. The trouble here is that the brains of the fund may leave, and investors would never know it until they saw the drop in their fund’s performance

Why we prefer ETF index funds over buying index mutual funds

1. Index ETFs offer you a lower-cost alternative to index mutual funds. With fees as low as 0.10% a year for index ETFs vs. index mutual funds that can charge you 1.20% or higher on their funds, ETFs can save you a lot of money and boost your returns if you are investing over time.
2. Index ETFs trade on stock exchanges, just like stocks. That’s different from index mutual funds, which you can only buy at the end of the day at a price that reflects the fund’s value at the close of trading.
3. Low turnover for index ETFs. Shares are added or removed when the underlying index changes. But with ETFs, you won’t incur the regular capital gains taxes generated by the yearly distributions most conventional index mutual funds pay out to unitholders.

If you want to invest in Canadian index ETFs, we routinely update subscribers to our Canadian Wealth Advisor newsletter on the best deals available. One example is the iShares S&P/TSX 60 Index ETF (Toronto symbol XIU). The fund’s units are made up of stocks that represent the S&P/TSX 60 Index, which consists of the 60 largest, most heavily traded stocks on the exchange. Most of the stocks in the index are high-quality companies. You pay a commission to buy this fund (through a broker), but the fund’s yearly expenses are just 0.18% of assets.

If you decide to invest in individual stocks, as well as Canadian index mutual funds or ETFs, you should take care to spread your money out across the five main economic sectors: Finance, Utilities, Consumer, Resources & Commodities, and Manufacturing & Industry.

By diversifying across most if not all of the five sectors, you avoid overloading yourself with stocks that are about to slump simply because of industry conditions or investor fashion.

You also increase your chances of stumbling upon a market superstar—a stock that does two to three or more times better than the market average.

In summary, this article discusses the advantages and considerations of Canadian index mutual funds and ETFs, highlighting their role in the investment landscape. It explains that while Canadian index mutual funds have been a significant financial innovation, ETFs are gaining popularity due to their even lower fees. The article outlines the benefits of index funds, including their ability to match market performance and provide low-cost exposure to the stock market. It also offers three key tips for investing in mutual funds: avoiding heavy traders, being cautious of vaguely described funds, and steering clear of anonymously managed funds.

The piece then compares index mutual funds to ETFs, noting that ETFs often have lower fees, trade like stocks, and offer tax advantages. It suggests that ETFs, such as the iShares S&P/TSX 60 Index ETF, may be preferable for many investors. The article concludes by emphasizing the importance of diversification across economic sectors when investing in individual stocks alongside funds. Throughout the content, the importance of choosing the best Canadian mutual funds is emphasized, highlighting the need for careful consideration and research when making investment decisions.

Have you invested in Canadian index mutual funds or ETFs? Have they been profitable for you?  Share your experience with us in the comments below.

This article was originally published in 2015 and is regularly updated.