Topic: How To Invest

Investor Toolkit: The trouble with technical analysis

Investor Toolkit: The trouble with technical analysis

Every Wednesday, we publish our “Investor Toolkit” series on TSI Network. Whether you’re a beginning or experienced investor, these weekly updates are designed to give you specific investment advice. Each Investor Toolkit update gives you a fundamental piece of investing strategy, and shows you how you can put it into practice right away.

Today’s tip: “Technical analysis may occasionally seem like an effective guide to picking stocks, but it can’t tell you enough about a stock to be consistently reliable.”

Some investors rely on technical analysis (which is basically chart reading) when they’re picking stocks. Relying on charts seems much simpler than delving into and weighing a company’s fundamentals.

There are successful investors who find that it helps to know some things about charts. But if you rely on charts at all, you should view them as just one of many things to consider when you make investment decisions.

How Successful Investors Get RICH

Learn everything you need to know in 'The Canadian Guide on How to Invest in Stocks Successfully' for FREE from The Successful Investor.

How to Invest In Stocks Guide: Find 10 factors that make your investments safer and stronger.

 I consent to receiving information from The Successful Investor via email. I understand I can unsubscribe from these updates at any time.

Narrow focus on the movement of stock prices ignores crucial information

The main problem with technical analysis is that it focuses too narrowly on a stock’s past price movements in an attempt to determine its future price. It’s not really concerned with any other crucial parts of a company’s business, such as financial statements or management. Rather, it just zeroes in on how stock prices have behaved in the past, and the clues that may offer about future price movements.

In fact, an investor who relies solely only charts might buy and sell a stock while knowing little or nothing about the underlying company.

The appeal of reading charts is that this approach often seems to work, at least in small ways. But this may be an illusion. Chances are you may only remember your successful chart interpretations. More important, this kind of analysis tends to work in spurts. The risk is that it might lead you to make five or even 10 small wins—and then it could very well steer you wrong at the worst possible moment. That next mistaken trade may cost you a lot more than your winnings to date.

Our investment advice. Use technical analysis to support—not determine—your view of a company. A far better approach is to look at chart reading as one tool among many. Above all, don’t look at the chart for a prediction of what’s going to happen. Look to see if the pattern on the chart appears to support your view of the stock, based on its finances and other fundamentals. But remember that the stock market follows a multitude of factors to varying extents, and the most important or influential factors will change continually.

Of course it’s encouraging if your analysis and the chart seem to match. But sometimes they don’t. If a company looks promising, but its chart shows a lengthy falling trend, insiders may know something you don’t. That’s when you know you have to dig deeper, and perhaps wait until the situation clarifies itself.

COMMENTS PLEASE—Share your investment experience and opinions with fellow TSINetwork.ca members

Can you think of a specific example in which a trend indicated by technical analysis helped you make a good decision on a stock? Or an example in which technical indicators misled you about a stock? Is there a particular form of technical analysis that you find useful? Let us know what you think.

Comments

  • Chris 

    Agree in general and especially understanding the play behind the play which a chart never shows. However, technical charts are very useful to see if a stock is trading at a 52 week high (don’t buy!) or if it has reached a key support level and is turning back up (possible buy but be careful of dead cat bounces!)

  • William 

    Hi Pat,

    It’s an interesting coincidence that you should post this 10 minutes after I sold Pengrowth. Again. Over the years I have made a few dollars by selling this stock whenever it goes up. When I buy it I intend to hold onto it for the dividend. But the chart is so horrendous that I can’t resist taking a profit, when the opportunity presents itself. I realize that’s not a sound investment strategy but with this particular stock I’m glad I followed it. If I had hung onto it from the day I bought it, on your recommendation, years ago I would be deeply in the hole.

    Frankly, where this stock is concerned I believe you rely a little too much on it’s fundamentals while ignoring it’s technicals. Over the long term it has gone almost straight down yet you continue to rate it’s risk as average. This is also true of other high-yielding oil and gas stocks you recommend. I still hold a few, and keep my fingers crossed hoping they will at least climb back to the price at which I purchased them.

    Otherwise I am very pleased with your recommendations.

    (And if Pengrowth falls again, I will repurchase it.)

    A satisfied customer.

  • Anthony 

    I have had trouble with “stop prices” as some analysts use very tight 10% stop that cause sales in volatile markets whilst others use a 25% stop that looses too much money particularly when a shareholder dumps his holding often after a dividend has been paid then the stock recovers back to its original price and its too late to reinvest!

  • Frank 

    Pat;

    I read with interest your comments on technical analysis and cannot wholely agree.

    To make it all make sense you will have to read the book ( How to make the stock market make money for you ) BY Ted Warren.

    It was based on the stock market but works equatly as well on the futures market.

    Frank.

Tell Us What YOU Think

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Please be respectful with your comments and help us keep this an area that everyone can enjoy. If you believe a comment is abusive or otherwise violates our Terms of Use, please click here to report it to the administrator.